The FBI has dismissed about 20 agents who were photographed kneeling during protests in 2020, a decision that has sparked controversy within law enforcement and political circles. The agents, who held a range of positions across multiple field offices, were reportedly seen kneeling as part of solidarity or reflection during demonstrations following the killing of George Floyd.
According to officials, the dismissals were tied to the agents’ conduct during official duties, which seemingly violated policies requiring political neutrality and impartiality while in uniform or on duty. Critics argue the firings could set a precedent for policing personal expression within federal agencies, raising concerns about the balance between free speech and professional conduct.
The decision has drawn criticism from civil rights groups and some members of Congress, who argue that kneeling during a protest does not equate to a violation of the oath to uphold the law. Others, however, see the move as necessary to maintain public trust in the impartiality of the FBI and avoid perceptions of bias within law enforcement ranks.
The FBI historically has expected all personnel to follow the highest standards of professional conduct and is not forthcoming behind their process and reasoning. Earlier this year, the organization had reassigned the agents to other duties. The FBI Agent Assoication released a statement on September 10 warning that agents may have limited recourse due to the classified nature of internal investigations and the discretion afforded to federal law enforcement leadership in disciplinary matters.
The firings come as the FBI continues to navigate the complex legacy of its response to protests and ongoing scrutiny over its role in politically charged investigations. The bureau has not specified whether additional disciplinary actions are expected, but the decision is already fueling debate over civil liberties, agency culture, and the boundaries of employee expression in federal service.